Showing posts with label NHS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NHS. Show all posts

Monday, 15 January 2018

Delivering a dementia diagnosis

There are many times in a person’s life with dementia that are described as pivotal. Often these are the difficult, crisis occasions that create the negative narrative that is so commonly associated with dementia. But after my recent personal experiences of dementia in my wider family, I’ve found myself reflecting on what I feel is arguably one of the most, if not THE most pivotal moment in a person’s life with dementia - their diagnosis.

As I’ve written about many times, my dad’s diagnosis took ten years, involved a catalogue of missed opportunities, a crisis that could have killed him, and ultimately when we finally heard the words that he’d been formally diagnosed with dementia, they came when we visited him in hospital and found his bed empty. The nurse said he’d been moved to the Elderly Mentally Infirm (EMI) Unit having been diagnosed with dementia.

Fast forward 14.5 years and for most people in the UK things have improved. We now have memory clinics, and the voluntary Memory Services National Accreditation Programme (MSNAP) from the Royal College of Psychiatrists that involves regular peer reviews (I am an MSNAP Peer Reviewer). Multidisciplinary teams staff these clinics, bringing a wealth of different skills and experiences that are vital in giving patients the very best diagnostic experience.

But not everyone has the type of experience I’ve seen in some of the best memory clinics in England, and when the experience isn’t good the effects last long after the doctor has delivered their clinical judgement. Listening to the diagnostic experience one of my in-laws had in South Africa last year left me with a mixture of sadness and anger - no person should have such a poor experience given all of the best practice examples available from many different countries (including the UK), and bear in mind that we are talking about private healthcare here, where the person is the very definition of a consumer.

My feelings left me reflecting on what a good experience really looks like from the person’s perspective, and I want to share those thoughts with you for this, my first D4Dementia blog of 2018. Whether you are a person concerned you may be developing dementia and could be seeking an explanation for your symptoms in the coming months, a relative worried about a loved one who you may go on to accompany to diagnostic appointments, or a clinician responsible for any part of the diagnostic pathway, I hope this list will help you.

1)     The person must own their diagnosis

This is the singularly most important aspect of diagnosis. Dementia remains stigmatised, particularly amongst older generations who still remember the asylums and labels of ‘madness’ that may have formed their viewpoint of dementia many years ago. The person needs to be personally involved and addressed at every point in the diagnostic process, and when the final verdict is delivered, it has to be communicated to the person first and foremost, in the most appropriate way for that person and by the most appropriate clinician. Anything less than this and the risk of the person not believing or trusting in the diagnostic process and the outcome of it will massively increase, which in turn can have long-term ramifications.

2)     Family can help... and hinder

It’s often said that a dementia diagnosis isn’t just given to the person, but to their whole family and wider network. Whilst as a daughter whose father lived with dementia I would agree with that, there is always a temptation to involve family members in the diagnostic process more than the person themselves, sidelining the very individual who is potentially living with dementia. Clinicians often choose to speak to family members because it’s perceived as easier and the information being gathered is seen as more reliable. At best that’s insulting. At worst it pits family members against their loved one with dementia. Marginalising the person is likely to leave that individual feeling that everyone is ganging up against them, which is a recipe for destroying relationships at the very time when they need to be at their strongest.

3)     The diagnostic process must be fair and thorough

For a person to believe and trust in their diagnosis, the process must be comprehensive, transparent, never rushed and totally individualised. Attempting even preliminary investigations when the person is unwell with another condition or infection is, in my view, utterly unacceptable. The person must be at their best to know in their own mind that they are able to give of their best in tests. Equally from a clinical perspective, you want an accurate measurement of the person’s baseline or, if you are tracking from a baseline, an accurate picture of where the person is now. Diagnosing just to tick a box, earn a financial reward (as has been available in the past in England) or prescribe certain drugs is never, ever justifiable.

4) A few words that change a person’s life

I’ve been very lucky in my work with MSNAP to hear from many people living with dementia and their family members who’ve had nothing but praise for the doctors, nurses, therapists and advisors who they’ve encountered during their diagnostic experience. How the diagnosis is delivered is a key marker we look for during MSNAP peer reviews and with good reason. An empathetic clinician who delivers the news of a dementia diagnosis with kindness and clarity, tailoring the level of information to the person, understanding what a momentous moment it is for the person, and allowing time and space for their carefully-chosen words to sink in is a clinician others less adept in these situations could learn a huge amount from.

5) Don’t abandon the person and their family

I couldn’t write a blog about diagnosis and not touch on one of the aspects of dementia care and support that I am most passionate about - post-diagnostic support. Even when a diagnostic process has fulfilled all of the aspects I’ve outlined above, the weeks and months after the person’s diagnosis can leave the individual and their family feeling abandoned and having to cope alone. This is when the risk of depression for all concerned can exponentially increase, and life can begin to unravel pretty rapidly and most definitely not in the direction of ‘living well’. Accessing peer support (including through DEEP and DAI), carer support, making environmental modifications, exploring rehabilitation, reablement and therapies to combat distressing symptoms are just a few ways to ensure that a good diagnostic experience is followed by an equally positive post-diagnostic experience.

Until next time...
Beth x







You can follow me on Twitter: @bethyb1886
Like D4Dementia on Facebook

Monday, 14 August 2017

The failure of post-diagnosis support

It’s not often that the content of TV programmes stays with me, but the recent BBC ‘Hospital’ series, following the fortunes of patients and staff at Imperial Trust’s hospitals in London, and ‘Granddad, dementia and me’ that I wrote about last month, both fall into that category.

Documentaries can teach us a lot, and even allowing for the selective nature of TV editing and the luxury of being a passive viewer rather than a stressed subject with a camera pointing at you, I feel it’s important that the learning from these two programmes isn’t lost.

The third episode of ‘Hospital’ featured two gentlemen living with dementia. Firstly we were introduced to Carl:

Narrator: “75-year-old Carl has dementia. His family brought him to A&E after he became aggressive at home. Yesterday morning he walked out of the hospital and was missing for 13 hours. The police found him wandering the streets alone and brought him back to A&E.”

Dr Barbara Cleaver, Emergency Medicine Consultant: “Three people to look after him at the moment including security because he is in an unfamiliar environment, it’s noisy, it’s bright, there’s lots going on. I suspect that’s really playing into his underlying diagnosis and making things much worse for him.”

Narrator: “For his own safety, Carl is being held in room Q, the space reserved for psychiatric patients.”

My alternative commentary would be:

“Carl, a gentleman living with dementia, was missing his wife who for her own health needed a break from 24/7 unsupported caring. Carl, confused and frustrated that he couldn’t find his wife, lashed out at those around him through no fault of his own, and without the skills and support they needed, family members took Carl to a place they thought he would be safe. Carl, however, became disorientated in this alien environment and went to look for his wife for reassurance and familiarity.”

Later, we were introduced to Stanley:

Narrator: “85-year-old Stanley has vascular dementia. This is his 4th admission in three months. Around 25% medical patients treated annually by the Trust have dementia. They are accommodated in a specialist ward until their social care can be arranged.”

My alternative commentary would be:

“Stanley, poorly supported in the community, has had repeated inpatient stays. At present Stanley does not require acute medical treatment, and would undoubtedly have lived far better with his dementia had his family and social care been properly resourced to support Stanley from his diagnosis onwards.”

Were Carl and Stanley featured because their stories are somehow usual? Sadly I suspect quite the opposite. Carl and Stanley are the norm. The failure in post-diagnosis support for people living with dementia and their families is something I have written about countless times. Not only is it a disgrace that families end up in the situations faced by Carl and Stanley, it is also a complete false economy.

My dad was diagnosed 14 years ago. Since then we’ve had numerous dementia-related initiatives from different governments and significant investment into dementia education for healthcare professionals via Health Education England. And yet we still have:

·       People attending A&E because it’s the only place guaranteed to ‘do’ something for them when their family can’t cope with ‘aggression’ or the person has been found ‘wandering’ (not my choice of language)

·       People with dementia being placed in rooms intended for psychiatric patients (that are not remotely dementia friendly)

·       Medical and security staff seemingly untrained in supporting a person with dementia (and loads of stigmatizing language)

·       People remaining stuck in hospital because care packages are so difficult to arrange

·       Family carers at their wits end, wanting to care for their loved one but utterly unsupported

·       No signs of dementia friendly environments (in people's own homes or health/social care facilities)
 
·       No mention of some of the good work that has been done to help people in hospital, like 'This is me' and John's Campaign.

Add in what we saw in ‘Granddad, dementia and me’ where the gentleman featured who was living with dementia, Tom, was drugged and sectioned, and overall in both programmes precious little sign of any choice, control, empowerment, peer support, occupation or activity, life story work and other non-pharmacological treatments, positive behaviour support or, frankly, anything I would be proud of (beyond the outcome shown in Tom story) and I honestly question how much REAL progress has been made in the last 14 years.

By the time a person attends A&E, there have potentially been numerous red-flags that the family needed support. A dementia diagnosis in itself is the first of these. Once things get so out of control that the person is in hospital (which is one of the worst possible environments for a person with dementia - it will only increase the person's confusion and disorientation making them upset and/or angry), the effect on everyone involved isn’t favourable.

Some simple preventative advice and support could at best avoid, or at least significantly delay, a person ever ending up in a crisis situation. Why do we not educate families, at diagnosis and continually thereafter, about (in no particular order):

·       Making their home dementia friendly

·       Accessing peer support and empowerment

·       Occupation and activity - The myriad of different options to keep busy and how to access them

·       Collating and using life stories and other non-pharmacological therapies to support a person experiencing changed behaviour

·       Training: For the person with dementia and anyone in the family unit who wants it. Knowledge is power for many people. Knowing what is happening in the person’s brain, how those changes could affect the person and ways of providing optimal care and support (including self-care for the person with dementia)

·        Carer resilience - Ways of coping, identifying when you aren’t coping and sources of support when you aren’t coping (that actually exist and respond)

Instead, as episode three of ‘Hospital’ concluded, we learnt that Carl was now being cared for in an acute mental health unit and visited daily by his wife, and Stanley was settling in well to his care home. Would either of these gentlemen have chosen these two places of residence? I doubt it. And from the perspective of the tax payer, both are very expensive options (Stanley’s care home costs £1700 a week, plus because of his ‘complex needs’, an additional £2300 for one-to-one care. It is funded by NHS Continuing Healthcare. We never learn what Carl’s acute mental health bed costs).

Worst of all though, is the cost in personal anguish for these two gentleman and their families. We’ve only very briefly dipped into their stories, but they represent examples being replicated every day of how a diagnosis of dementia can needlessly lead to lives unravelling, all for the want of a holistic, long-term package of what is comparatively low-level post-diagnosis support.
 
Ask yourself: For a country aiming to be the best place in the world for people with dementia to live, is that the best we can do?

Until next time...
Beth x







You can follow me on Twitter: @bethyb1886

Monday, 25 July 2016

Reframing the reporting about violent older people in hospitals

Recently the BBC ran a story that over 75's are responsible for 57% of physical assaults on NHS staff in hospitals. These assaults range from biting and pinching through to some of the most serious attacks that are recorded. In trying to explain why these incidents are happening, the stress and confusion that a hospital stay can cause were highlighted, and patients who are living with the effects of dementia were inevitably mentioned.

Sadly, I think many people reading the headline and acknowledging that dementia is mentioned will, yet again, assume that all people with dementia are violent. Little consideration will be given to how hospital environments contributed to the circumstances around these incidents, or indeed how the lack of comprehensive staff training or appropriate staffing numbers did likewise.

What also won't be examined is how many people were avoidably in hospital in the first place, or who had remained there for far too long when not clinically necessary because of failings in the availability, organisation or funding of social care places. It's just quick and simple to look at older people and say: "They are violent because they have dementia and are attacking the people trying to care for them."

What has to be understood is that people with all different dispositions and from all walks of life develop dementia. If you were an unpleasant person with a quick temper and a tendency to be violent prior to developing dementia, your dementia may or may not make those character traits more pronounced.

Likewise, for some people who were mild-mannered and never hurt anyone, the development of dementia can lead to symptoms such as paranoia, hallucinations, disorientation, confusion and anxiety that can result in a person lashing out without realising they are or without intending to. It is simply their reaction to what they are experiencing in that moment, allied with the circumstances (environment, staffing etc) that they are in the midst of.

Delirium and other mental health problems that either haven't been diagnosed or aren't being well treated can also contribute, not to mention the side-effects of a medication, poly-pharmacy or indeed something as simple as a urinary tract infection, being hungry or tired - do not underestimate the effect of sleep deprivation. A person may also feel angry, ashamed or undignified if they aren't being supported to wash, use the toilet or be mobile in the way they would want to be, resulting in feeling uncomfortable or becoming incontinent or immobile.

I am not in any way making excuses for violence against NHS staff, nor would I ever condone it, but before we brand older people as violent patients I think we need to understand how being a hospital patient can make you feel.

Last year I spent one night in hospital following the birth of our daughter. All the care I received was wonderful and the staff were very kind and helpful to me. But I didn't sleep a wink. Nor did I particularly like the food. I definitely wanted to lock the bathroom door when I went for a shower, and ideally would have preferred to keep the curtains around my bed closed, but because we all had to be in view of the staff so we could be monitored, that wasn't possible except for breastfeeding or getting dressed.

Granted, I had just had a baby and hormones were going wild, but fundamentally I was a knowledgeable, articulate person who could speak up for myself and wasn't in danger of having to stay in hospital any longer than was absolutely necessary. Yet I felt vulnerable. And if I can feel vulnerable, then I can only imagine how an older person, potentially with reduced communication abilities due to their health, might feel.

I have written before about how undiagnosed pain in a person with dementia can affect that person. I've also written about unmet needs being misunderstood as 'challenging behaviour' (a phrase I hate), and about the effects of illness, incontinence, hunger, dehydration and sleep problems. I've also addressed the shortcomings in hospital environments for older people in comparison to the environments we offer children.

All of these issues can easily converge and result in avoidable incidents. Aggression is so strongly linked to dementia that I meet people who are surprised if their loved one isn't aggressive. Yet there is so much that can be done through person-centred care, occupation, reablement/rehabilitative support and life-story work to support people with dementia to cope with their symptoms.

Whilst the BBC based their story on firm evidence, with figures obtained from NHS Protect (the organisation dealing with crime across the health service), I suspect that many people simply won't see beyond the statistics and examine the real issues, let alone tackle them. As a result fear of having contact with older people and people who have dementia proliferates. With such ostracisation comes isolation, and an even greater chance of people who are already feeling misunderstood reacting to that in ways that hurt them every bit as much as those trying to provide care and support for them.

Understanding about dementia has improved over the years, but it isn't where it needs to be to provide appropriate, individualised support for every person. Geriatrics isn't an area of medicine that is oversubscribed with our brightest and best professionals in the way paediatrics might be considered to be, and ageing within our society still isn't universally viewed with dignity, respect or compassion. Often older people's services are underfunded, stretched to capacity (and beyond) and seen as little more than a 'dumping ground' for people viewed as adult babies and stripped of their identity.

We are long overdue a complete re-evaluation of how we care for older people in hospital, including the need to even be in hospital to begin with, and an honest stock-take on how circumstances (many of which we can control) result in incidents that are then beyond anyone's control, least of all the patients at the centre of them. As in all areas of healthcare, prevention is always better than cure.

Until next time...
Beth x







You can follow me on Twitter: @bethyb1886

Monday, 8 February 2016

GP's and care homes - A relationship under pressure

When I first read that GP's were proposing to alter their current arrangements for visiting care homes, I wasn't surprised. Back when my dad was living in care homes, GP's were already under considerable pressure. I know that one of my dad's care providers had to pay for GP visits, and even then some of the younger GP's in the practice were reluctant to visit the home when residents were quite poorly.

By contrast, the senior GP in the practice visited regularly, had a lovely bedside manner (he was a tall man and would kneel on the floor so that he was at dad's eye level to chat to him), and even attended one of our relatives meetings to discuss providing healthcare for the residents and long-term planning.

I recall arguing with one particular young female GP about whether dad had any 'quality of life' and whether or not he should be given antibiotics for a chest infection (in my view he had quality of life, and he got the antibiotics in the end, which cleared his infection). I also remember possibly the worst experience I'd ever had with a doctor, when an out-of-hours GP visited late one Saturday evening and refused to even touch dad to examine him.

That experience with the out-of-hours GP is perhaps a glimpse into the future whereby the services of the local GP practice could, potentially, be replaced with privately contracted GP's who may not provide the same level of continuity or personalisation. It is not a scenario I welcome or look forward to in any shape or form.

It is my view that a regularly visiting, local GP is absolutely vital to the provision of high quality care in care homes. A good local GP will get to know their patients, pick up on illnesses and conditions quickly, keep medication under review, and provide a useful external oversight role in relation to how well the care home are caring for their residents.

I appreciate that general practice is under severe, unprecedented pressure and needs additional funding, but there is no suggestion that care for other sectors of society needs a separate contractual arrangement with the government and for that reason this feels like victimisation. The argument from GP representatives is that care homes are becoming extensions of hospital wards, and the needs of the people living in them are increasingly unmanageable for local GP's within the current structure and funding of general practice.

It is undoubtedly true that care homes have changed from what they were. Traditionally a residential home accommodated people of relative ability who just needed a bit of assistance with personal care, low level health needs and some companionship, while nursing homes offered the same but with a registered nurse on duty to support people with more extensive health needs, medications etc.

However as people live longer, have more complex long-term conditions, and the NHS is under pressure to discharge people back into the community, it's fair to say that a lot of residential homes have become more like the traditional nursing home model, and the nursing homes of today have morphed into mock hospital wards. But that isn't the fault of the people living there. They aren't in hospital, so don't have access to hospital doctors - the only way they can have care from a doctor is from a GP practice.

By all means GP's need to raise their concerns with the government and seek additional support to continue to provide the care that people in care homes need, but if the government don't agree to a separate contractual agreement to cover GP care in care homes, it would be wholly wrong for care for this sector of society to be withdrawn. People in care homes rarely ask to be living there, and they are as entitled to care from their local family doctor as anyone else. For these individuals, their care home is their home - they shouldn't be penalised for living in a care home by losing their local GP service.

I appreciate that GP practices work best when patients visit them rather than when GP's have to conduct home visits, but if the patient can't get to the surgery then the GP needs to go to them, regardless of where they live. Yes, care homes may have the option of buying in private GP care (if indeed they could afford it, which is highly questionable for many), but from the perspective of residents that isn't the same as having your own local GP who gets to know you and your needs.

If new contractual arrangements with GP's aren't forthcoming, I fear that individuals with dementia may be hit the hardest. For this group of people continuity of care is vital. A good local GP who understands the person - and understands dementia - can make a huge difference to the life of an individual with dementia, as we saw first hand with that senior GP whose interactions with dad were a real joy to see.

Families also rely on good local GP's to help and advise them on the different conditions their loved one has, the various medications they are (or could) be taking, and when discussions need to be had in relation to long-term planning and end-of-life care. Keeping people in their care home for end-of-life care is infinitely preferable to being in hospital, but good local GP support is vital to facilitate that.

I hope that GP's and the government will manage to find a mutually agreeable compromise, and that this issue doesn't escalate in the way the junior doctors contract has. Without such a compromise the people who suffer most will, yet again, be some of the most vulnerable in society, a fact that shames us all.

Until next time...
Beth x







You can follow me on Twitter: @bethyb1886
LIKE D4Dementia on Facebook

Please note: This blog was modified on 12 February 2016 due to information received.

Monday, 25 January 2016

Fixing dementia care in hospitals

Standards of hospital care for people with dementia made the news last week, with an investigation by the Alzheimer's Society showing shocking variations in the quality of care being given, prompting the charity to launch their 'Fix Dementia Care' campaign.

Given that this time four years ago my father was still alive, and had been the recipient of some extremely variable hospital care in the years prior to 2012, it is a source of huge concern and sadness for me that many of the problems we experienced continue today.

The Freedom of Information requests that provided the substance for the Alzheimer's Society investigation highlighted that people with dementia were:

•    Falling while in hospital

•    Being discharged at night

•    Being marooned in hospital despite their medical treatment having finished 

Whilst my dad thankfully never had a fall whilst in hospital, being discharged at night was something he experienced on almost every inpatient stay. The reason given in his latter years with dementia when he was completely immobile was that he needed transportation via ambulance, and this was most easily accomplished at night when paramedics were less busy. Never mind what dad might have wanted of course.
 
I suspect the fact that he was being discharged to a nursing home, with staffing 24 hours a day, was also a somewhat convenient excuse. It was, however, a horrible experience for dad - these events often came in winter, and being moved out into the cold night air when he should have been tucked up in a warm bed was, in my view, a particularly sadistic form of 'care' that would leave him upset, disorientated and confused.
 
Being marooned in hospital was also a harsh reality for dad - at one point he spent three months in hospital (despite being medically fit for discharge) whilst funding was arranged for the care home placement that his doctors said he needed. During this time dad lost half of his body weight and the NHS picked up a huge bill for his care - a no-win situation for all concerned.
 
Alongside collecting data from Freedom of Information requests, the investigation by the Alzheimer's Society surveyed people affected by dementia. They found that 92% of those individuals felt that hospital environments were frightening and only 2% felt that all hospital staff understood their needs. 
 
Reading this led me to reflect on how my dad might have responded to his hospital experiences. I'm certain he found the hospital environment pretty unpleasant, from the noise, smells and routines of hospital life, to difficulties in finding facilities like the toilet and having opportunities for stimulation, occupation or activity during the long days as an inpatient. Only on one particularly 'fortunate' stay in hospital could I honestly say that dad had a better experience - he had his own room and staff found him a CD player. We brought in CD's for dad and his mood changed completely. Simple stuff, but so effective.
 
Sadly, however, meeting staff who understood dad's needs wasn't the norm. During the latter years of dad's dementia when he had dysphagia (swallowing problems), hospital staff refused to allow him to have food or to help him eat it, mistaking his hunger cries for pain and writing him up for morphine. This was a 'mistake' that could be interpreted as covertly putting him onto an end-of-life pathway by administering a drug that he didn't need and could have shortened his life with an inappropriate dosage.
 
Furthermore, this 'mistake' was only rectified because dad had a family visiting him for eight hours a day, speaking up for him, and bringing him food and drinks and helping him to consume them. We would also assist him with his personal care - without that help a man who liked to be clean shaven would have begun to grow a beard. But what happens to people without this family support? Do they get inappropriately medicated, starved, dehydrated or left dirty, uncomfortable and neglected? The variations exposed in the quality of hospital care suggests that this is likely to be a reality for some people with dementia who are inpatients today.
 
Despite the many difficulties we encountered with hospital care, however, I don't want to paint a completely bleak picture. There were good experiences, staff who genuinely cared and understood what dad needed, as well as providing great support for us. This was particularly evident in dad's last stay in hospital when he'd been rushed in with an aspiration pneumonia. 
 
His care was excellent, with the doctors treating him taking a lot of time and trouble during their interactions with dad and in their care for him, alongside explaining things to us and giving us time. Our decision to seek end of life care for dad from a care home wasn't because we were unhappy with his hospital care, but rather that the hospital couldn't offer the homely environment or privacy we felt he needed as his life approached its final stages. 
 
So, how do we ensure that hospital care is a high quality experience for every person with dementia? In my view providing comprehensive dementia education for all hospital staff (which Health Education England are tasked with delivering) and making environments more dementia friendly will only go so far.
 
The root of much of what is wrong stems from compartmentalisation. Hospitals work best when a person is admitted with one condition and treated for that condition. However, people with dementia often live with other conditions alongside their dementia, and are usually always admitted into general hospitals not because of their dementia but because of infections (mostly notably chest and urine infections), another long-term condition (like diabetes, heart disease or asthma) that hasn't been well managed, or because they've had a fall in their own home or in a care home.
 
This was never more evident for us than when dad needed hospital care during the last four years of his life when he had dysphagia. Treating a gentleman with dysphagia who also had dementia and all the challenges that brings around communication was an alien concept for most hospital staff, with approaches varying from the starvation I mentioned above, to trying to force a tube through his nose into his tummy rather than orally proving food (a tube he promptly pulled out), and providing ice cream (that quickly melted) as a suitable 'thickened' food for him (which in reality was as liquid as the water out of the tap).
 
What is needed to combat these issues is more holistic, joined up care that sees each person as a whole human being and treats them as such regardless of how many problems they have with their health and which of these problems has led them to be hospitalised. This approach needs to be combined with a comprehensive 24/7 service that enables individuals to access the care and support that they need when they need it. People can become unwell on any day and at any time - prompt treatment and, crucially, the availability of care and support when they are ready to leave hospital, is vital. 
 
Furthermore, if hospitals that are underperforming (as highlighted by the Alzheimer's Society Freedom of Information Requests) learnt from the hospitals who are providing some of the excellent care that the Alzheimer's Society found, these huge variations in care would become a thing of the past. It heartens me that some outstanding care does exist, but I remain saddened that so little seems to have improved since my dad was living with dementia. Clearly we still have a lot to learn.
 
Until next time...
Beth x







You can follow me on Twitter: @bethyb1886

 

Monday, 31 August 2015

Playing the numbers game

I write this blog on the cusp of September which is the 4th World Alzheimer’s Month, a yearly international campaign to raise awareness and challenge stigma. Two announcements in August, both around prevalence, have kept dementia in the news. In case you missed them, here are the links: The Lancet and Alzheimer’s Disease International.

I’ve written before about my scepticism of dementia statistics. I am particularly wary of prevalence data and the dreaded ‘predicted’ numbers of people expected to develop dementia. I don’t feel the methodology behind many of these figures is anywhere near as robust as it should be, and whilst numbers make great headlines, I don’t feel they serve wider society well. In fact I’ve often wondered why we see so many statistics on the numbers of people predicted to develop dementia and yet so few figures for the numbers of services available, or the availability and uptake of different methods for living well with dementia.

Last time prevalence figures were revised downwards, I heard many whisperings of discontent from those who either work within or on the periphery of English dementia policy. It’s astonishing to consider that some people might not welcome such data, however questionable the methodology behind it is, but then dementia has been on an almost unstoppable bandwagon of negativity and doom and gloom headlines ever since the PM’s Dementia Challenge ignited unprecedented interest in the ‘D’ word.

The prospect that less people than previously thought may now go on to develop dementia in the UK is something to be applauded in my view, although I’m not convinced it has anything to do with lifestyle modifications being made by the population. I suspect these new predictions are just attempting to correct previously dubious data. I’d love to think that the population are taking precautions to improve their health by following preventative advice relating to diet, exercise and lifestyle, but I personally don’t feel those messages are anywhere near as embedded as they should, or need, to be.

Meanwhile of course, the Alzheimer’s Disease International (ADI) report paints a picture of increasing rates of dementia worldwide, and highlights how low and middle income countries in particular are likely to be affected by growing rates of dementia development in the years ahead. Without the health and care infrastructure we enjoy in the UK (however fragmented it is), not to mention lower levels of education and awareness, these predictions from ADI seem eminently sensible, albeit offering a huge challenge to the global community to try and offer people at risk of developing dementia, or already living with dementia, in these countries a chance to live a better life than they might otherwise have access to.

So how do we unpick all of this and become more informed citizens? A good place to start is by ignoring headlines that predict doom one day and a cure the next, and that play the numbers game by quoting figures that may appear very authoritative but in essence are based on what mostly amounts to some very complex analytical guesswork. In the same way that the rhetoric of loss associated with dementia and so avidly repeated in the media does nothing to help families navigate their way with dementia in positive and practical ways. The recent 'Dementiaville' programme was a classic example – if they told us once that the families featured were losing their loved ones to dementia they told us a hundred times.

Looking back, I suspect part of the reason why I was able to enjoy time with my dad in his latter years with dementia, and look back so fondly on much of what we did together is precisely because I didn’t inwardly digest statistics and negative portrayals of dementia. In saying that, I don’t for one moment underestimate the impact dementia has, it changed my father’s life and the lives of those around him in immeasurable ways, but it didn’t consume me. Living and loving and taking each day as it came was my coping strategy, not that I realised it at the time.

Whatever the rate of dementia prevalence is in the years ahead, it won’t change the fundamentals of living with dementia, and if cuts in social care services and our over-stretched NHS are anything to go by, whether the predictions of dementia prevalence are high or low doesn’t stop people being denied the care and support that they need. 

If anything we should to be less hung up on numbers and more focused on people. We also need to spend a lot more time and resources on those positive public health messages that are designed to keep people healthier for longer, and an awful lot more energy publicising and replicating some of the really great care and support mechanisms for dementia that a few people have access to but that many others do not.

Until next time...
Beth x







You can follow me on Twitter: @bethyb1886